Spoiler:
Science Fiction. The realm of fantasy and abnormal physics, with a laser gun or two thrown in the mix for fair measure. More than one galaxy call this genre home, two of the most popular being those of Star Trek and Star Wars. Many an enthusiastic fan has enjoyed contrasting the two vastly different franchises for decades, but this essay will simply compare a symbolic component of each. Namely, Star Trek’s Constitution class starship, and the Star Wars Imperial I class Star Destroyer.
Perhaps the most distinct difference, and easily the simplest to point out, is that of the premise of each vessel. While both are spacefaring vessels capable of combat actions, the intentions that mandated the addition of these characteristics to each craft are vastly different. The Star Destroyer’s very classification denotes the aggressive purposes for which it is designed. While it cannot literally lay waste to entities that are, for all intents and purposes, immune to contemporary weaponry, it does clearly function as a destroyer in a fleet that operates among the stars. By contrast, the Federation of Planets’ Constitution class starship is an exploratory vessel merely armed for the sake of self-defense.
A direct impact of this differentiation can be seen on the set of weaponry each ship carries. Perhaps belying the Constitution’s typical mission of diplomacy and trailblazing are 18 phaser emitters; directed energy cannons capable of inducing secondary reactions within a target’s hull itself. This makes even a single Constitution class a force to reckon with, particularly if one considers its dual photon torpedo launchers. In comparison, an Imperial-I class Star Destroyer mounts an impressive turbolaser armanent coupled with banks of ion cannons to provide offensive capability befitting that of a true warship. A group of Star Destroyers can easily slag portions of a planet’s crust through coordinated bombardment.
Personnel aboard the starcraft constitute the last major variance betwix the two. Clearly there are going to be some key differences in perspective between your typical Federation redshirt and Imperial Navy crewmember given their respective missions, but there’s one that stands above the rest. Constitution class ships, such as the Enterprise, have been cited multiple times to contain the ‘best and brightest of Starfleet’. Suffice to say, the same has never been said concerning Star Destroyers; indeed, in the movies there’s something to be said about the level of incompetence demonstrated by even ranking members of each Imperial’s crew. Granted, there’s probably some measure of deprecation among >25,000 count of Star Destroyers operating in the Empire’s name at its peak as opposed to the twelve or so Constitutions in the service of Starfleet, but this is an indicator of significant disparity between the crew complements staffing each vessel.
In conclusion, while it would not be an impossible task to draw similarities between the two warships, outside of the fundamentals the two share very little in common. Each is staffed almost entirely by humans, but can’t that be said of nearly every sci fi starcraft? Each can travel at faster-than-light speeds, but again, what self-respecting sci fi franchise doesn’t have a spacefaring battlecruiser capable of such? The Imperial Star Destroyer and Constitution class should therefore be considered very, very different ships.
Perhaps the most distinct difference, and easily the simplest to point out, is that of the premise of each vessel. While both are spacefaring vessels capable of combat actions, the intentions that mandated the addition of these characteristics to each craft are vastly different. The Star Destroyer’s very classification denotes the aggressive purposes for which it is designed. While it cannot literally lay waste to entities that are, for all intents and purposes, immune to contemporary weaponry, it does clearly function as a destroyer in a fleet that operates among the stars. By contrast, the Federation of Planets’ Constitution class starship is an exploratory vessel merely armed for the sake of self-defense.
A direct impact of this differentiation can be seen on the set of weaponry each ship carries. Perhaps belying the Constitution’s typical mission of diplomacy and trailblazing are 18 phaser emitters; directed energy cannons capable of inducing secondary reactions within a target’s hull itself. This makes even a single Constitution class a force to reckon with, particularly if one considers its dual photon torpedo launchers. In comparison, an Imperial-I class Star Destroyer mounts an impressive turbolaser armanent coupled with banks of ion cannons to provide offensive capability befitting that of a true warship. A group of Star Destroyers can easily slag portions of a planet’s crust through coordinated bombardment.
Personnel aboard the starcraft constitute the last major variance betwix the two. Clearly there are going to be some key differences in perspective between your typical Federation redshirt and Imperial Navy crewmember given their respective missions, but there’s one that stands above the rest. Constitution class ships, such as the Enterprise, have been cited multiple times to contain the ‘best and brightest of Starfleet’. Suffice to say, the same has never been said concerning Star Destroyers; indeed, in the movies there’s something to be said about the level of incompetence demonstrated by even ranking members of each Imperial’s crew. Granted, there’s probably some measure of deprecation among >25,000 count of Star Destroyers operating in the Empire’s name at its peak as opposed to the twelve or so Constitutions in the service of Starfleet, but this is an indicator of significant disparity between the crew complements staffing each vessel.
In conclusion, while it would not be an impossible task to draw similarities between the two warships, outside of the fundamentals the two share very little in common. Each is staffed almost entirely by humans, but can’t that be said of nearly every sci fi starcraft? Each can travel at faster-than-light speeds, but again, what self-respecting sci fi franchise doesn’t have a spacefaring battlecruiser capable of such? The Imperial Star Destroyer and Constitution class should therefore be considered very, very different ships.
[/spoiler]
