RP reset: psionics
It doesn't matter much for empire RPs and it doesn't matter how well it works in a game. The discussion has very little bearing on ERPs.
"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from a completely ad-hoc plot device"
— David Langford
— David Langford
Spoiler:
-
- Vice Admiral
- Posts:2312
- Joined:Sun Dec 09, 2012 10:21 pm
- Affiliation:Strigiforme
- IGN:ACH0225
- Location:Cuuyth
Re: RP reset: psionics
Shouldn't it be tailored for ERPs, seeing as they are the most important/most participated RPs?
mfw brony imagesfr0stbyte124 wrote:5 months from now, I will publish a paper on an efficient method for rendering millions of owls to a screen.
Spoiler:
-
- Rear Admiral
- Posts:1890
- Joined:Sat Dec 01, 2012 9:39 am
- Affiliation:GLORIOUS REPUBLIC
Re: RP reset: psionics
If you design a system around any element it will be all but functionally useless when addressing anything beyond that. Seeing as the current crop of ERPs aren't canon, anyhow, the ideal approach then would be to avoid narrowing the focus of the mechanics to any particular niche and instead do what is best for the universe overall. I don't think many of you realize how much our lore pales in comparison to many other independent works out there...I would strongly advise against taking up the obstinate mentality that cockblocked progress a few weeks back if you truly want the fcverse to rise above its current status.
Re: RP reset: psionics
Least of all ERPs. They're about greater ends, not means. Movement of ships and troops, production, etc. The abilities of individuals are hardly relevant, why attempt to scale something up to tailor to the game in which the workings of the concept don't need to be written? "Because they're popular" isn't a good reason. They're only popular because they're still viewed as a game and don't require much effort to write an entry.
"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from a completely ad-hoc plot device"
— David Langford
— David Langford
Spoiler:
-
- Fleet Admiral
- Posts:3021
- Joined:Fri Dec 07, 2012 12:10 pm
- Affiliation:[redacted]
- IGN:Ivan2006
- Location:In a universe.
- Contact:
Re: RP reset: psionics
@Catsonmeth Please do not put emphasis on what psionics ARE. Because that is not even decided at this point, which is why this thread even exists in the first place, to sort out differences in our opinion.
Anyway, catsonmeth, it appears that we have a vastly different idea of psionics.
And the concept of "subspace" is not set in stone either AFAIK, it is clear that there's a lot of energy, but from what I could tell there is nothing that speaks against a) psionic energy being its own type of energy and b) part of the energy in subspace being psionic.
This is MY proposal to psionics.
You can go with that or agree on a better idea.
Again, my point is that as soon as we get to the point where psionics are mechanically used, we get psionic tech acting differently depending on how we define psionics. I think what we can agree on is that we need rules to psionics to avoid a) people using psionics to arsepull random tech and b) having a heated argument about what psionics can or can not do.
And we have to avoid people from making "magic power x" a psionic ability. While some "magic powers" would likely be replicable by psionics, no matter how we make them, we need a clear outline of what is possible with psionics.
My idea on psionic energy being its own type of energy is even backed up by science: There is an experiment where one person played the violin and another person, completely seperated with from any type of connection, including EM waves, started showing the same brain activity as the violin player. This makes it scientifically plausible that the "connection" between human brains is not transmitted by means of any known type of energy. However, energy is neccessarily required to transmit information, therefore it is plausible that a seperate type of energy exists, which, in my case would emitt EM waves in realspace (due to instability, as it is native to subspace), providing a connection to the also scientifically observed "Aura" phenomenon (humans emitting small quantities of visible light, been measured in a dark room). Of course, small EM fields would be emitted by human brains due to electric activity, but being a lot of small sources in the brain, they would mostly cancel each other out, not to mention that EM field would not emitt signs of chemical activity in the brain, useful interaction using that would be pretty much impossible..
On the topic of the whole "force of nature"-debate:
Okay, it propably is not a force of nature acting like Gravity, electromagnetism or the nuclear forces.
However, two things: One, Physics can not prove that there are no other, technically scientifically explainable, forces other than the currently known. Two, in my model, psionics is native to subspace and only ever enter realspace through psionic nodes in a controlled form. Question yourself, would you call the force exerted by an electromagnet in a coilgun on the projectile a "force of nature"? Propably not. Yet electromagnetism is a force of nature, it is just in a controlled and artificially created form. The term "force of nature" mainly means that it has a direct effect on the particles themselves. Whether psionics is controlled subspace energy or the means of controllign said energy would be a matter of definition of the word. This is why I am talking about "psionic energy" instead of psionics, as that would be the means of control. Psionic energy is the energy being controlled to have an effect on the environment. You need some kind of scientifically sensible interaction and psionic energy applying directed kinetic energy to objects on a sub-molecular level is honestly the best idea I can come up with.
For the necessity of psionics being responsible for "paranormal activity", the combination of a)psionic energy in subspace, b)psionic nodes being a connector allowing for that energy to influence realspace and c)psionic nodes being present in any human, is what creates the census as well, making it unneccessary to view it as a "force of nature".
On energy sources you wrote this:
Anyway, catsonmeth, it appears that we have a vastly different idea of psionics.
And the concept of "subspace" is not set in stone either AFAIK, it is clear that there's a lot of energy, but from what I could tell there is nothing that speaks against a) psionic energy being its own type of energy and b) part of the energy in subspace being psionic.
This is MY proposal to psionics.
You can go with that or agree on a better idea.
Again, my point is that as soon as we get to the point where psionics are mechanically used, we get psionic tech acting differently depending on how we define psionics. I think what we can agree on is that we need rules to psionics to avoid a) people using psionics to arsepull random tech and b) having a heated argument about what psionics can or can not do.
And we have to avoid people from making "magic power x" a psionic ability. While some "magic powers" would likely be replicable by psionics, no matter how we make them, we need a clear outline of what is possible with psionics.
My idea on psionic energy being its own type of energy is even backed up by science: There is an experiment where one person played the violin and another person, completely seperated with from any type of connection, including EM waves, started showing the same brain activity as the violin player. This makes it scientifically plausible that the "connection" between human brains is not transmitted by means of any known type of energy. However, energy is neccessarily required to transmit information, therefore it is plausible that a seperate type of energy exists, which, in my case would emitt EM waves in realspace (due to instability, as it is native to subspace), providing a connection to the also scientifically observed "Aura" phenomenon (humans emitting small quantities of visible light, been measured in a dark room). Of course, small EM fields would be emitted by human brains due to electric activity, but being a lot of small sources in the brain, they would mostly cancel each other out, not to mention that EM field would not emitt signs of chemical activity in the brain, useful interaction using that would be pretty much impossible..
On the topic of the whole "force of nature"-debate:
Okay, it propably is not a force of nature acting like Gravity, electromagnetism or the nuclear forces.
However, two things: One, Physics can not prove that there are no other, technically scientifically explainable, forces other than the currently known. Two, in my model, psionics is native to subspace and only ever enter realspace through psionic nodes in a controlled form. Question yourself, would you call the force exerted by an electromagnet in a coilgun on the projectile a "force of nature"? Propably not. Yet electromagnetism is a force of nature, it is just in a controlled and artificially created form. The term "force of nature" mainly means that it has a direct effect on the particles themselves. Whether psionics is controlled subspace energy or the means of controllign said energy would be a matter of definition of the word. This is why I am talking about "psionic energy" instead of psionics, as that would be the means of control. Psionic energy is the energy being controlled to have an effect on the environment. You need some kind of scientifically sensible interaction and psionic energy applying directed kinetic energy to objects on a sub-molecular level is honestly the best idea I can come up with.
For the necessity of psionics being responsible for "paranormal activity", the combination of a)psionic energy in subspace, b)psionic nodes being a connector allowing for that energy to influence realspace and c)psionic nodes being present in any human, is what creates the census as well, making it unneccessary to view it as a "force of nature".
On energy sources you wrote this:
I personally do not like the concept of the energy being produced by the psionically capable individual. I think that would require an overly complex mechanism that could not be reliably replicated by technology. Keep in mind that "psionic nodes drawing power fron subspace" would not be OP, as every node only allows a certain ammount of energy through, which would quickly dissipate and be quite hard to store, so an average psionic won't be capable of much beyond telepathy without technological or genetical aid. Psionic technology would operate by artificially maintaining a psionic node. Creating such an artificial psionic node would work by one of two means: a) focusing a lot of ambient psionic energy on a suitable "carrier" and mimicking the mechanism in the brain, hoping to cause a reaction and open a node. This method can only create limited ammounts of energy, for example a single psionic ship-to-ship weapon would require about 10 of those carriers. b) dimensional manipulation, would propably only become feasible in the far-future as described in your model. It would allow to create much larger nodes. This type would however be required to construct psionic subspace drives (note: change of plans, my faction will not start into the galaxy with psi-FTL. psi-FTL would only be developed much later, around the same time as regular subspace drives, due to the requirement of dimensional subspace manipulation being already available).catsonmeth wrote:The other issue is the energy source and means to broadcast the energy over distances. The energy could come from the organism itself. The average human takes in about 2000 kilocalories per day, which is about 2 KG TNT energy equivalent. Metabolism could be heightened by the wetware and used to feed it. Devices could also be used to gather ambient energy and store it, or just create their own. Interdimensional energy might also be a source, but only in the far-future.
Quotes:
Spoiler:
-
- Lt. Commander
- Posts:781
- Joined:Fri Dec 07, 2012 5:00 pm
- Affiliation:Darkstar Security CO
- Location:Brazil.
Re: RP reset: psionics
The limit of the Willing Suspension of Disbelief for a given element is directly proportional to the element's awesomeness.Ivan2006 wrote:@Catsonmeth Please do not put emphasis on what psionics ARE. Because that is not even decided at this point, which is why this thread even exists in the first place, to sort out differences in our opinion.
Anyway, catsonmeth, it appears that we have a vastly different idea of psionics.
And the concept of "subspace" is not set in stone either AFAIK, it is clear that there's a lot of energy, but from what I could tell there is nothing that speaks against a) psionic energy being its own type of energy and b) part of the energy in subspace being psionic.
This is MY proposal to psionics.
You can go with that or agree on a better idea.
Again, my point is that as soon as we get to the point where psionics are mechanically used, we get psionic tech acting differently depending on how we define psionics. I think what we can agree on is that we need rules to psionics to avoid a) people using psionics to arsepull random tech and b) having a heated argument about what psionics can or can not do.
And we have to avoid people from making "magic power x" a psionic ability. While some "magic powers" would likely be replicable by psionics, no matter how we make them, we need a clear outline of what is possible with psionics.
My idea on psionic energy being its own type of energy is even backed up by science: There is an experiment where one person played the violin and another person, completely seperated with from any type of connection, including EM waves, started showing the same brain activity as the violin player. This makes it scientifically plausible that the "connection" between human brains is not transmitted by means of any known type of energy. However, energy is neccessarily required to transmit information, therefore it is plausible that a seperate type of energy exists, which, in my case would emitt EM waves in realspace (due to instability, as it is native to subspace), providing a connection to the also scientifically observed "Aura" phenomenon (humans emitting small quantities of visible light, been measured in a dark room). Of course, small EM fields would be emitted by human brains due to electric activity, but being a lot of small sources in the brain, they would mostly cancel each other out, not to mention that EM field would not emitt signs of chemical activity in the brain, useful interaction using that would be pretty much impossible..
On the topic of the whole "force of nature"-debate:
Okay, it propably is not a force of nature acting like Gravity, electromagnetism or the nuclear forces.
However, two things: One, Physics can not prove that there are no other, technically scientifically explainable, forces other than the currently known. Two, in my model, psionics is native to subspace and only ever enter realspace through psionic nodes in a controlled form. Question yourself, would you call the force exerted by an electromagnet in a coilgun on the projectile a "force of nature"? Propably not. Yet electromagnetism is a force of nature, it is just in a controlled and artificially created form. The term "force of nature" mainly means that it has a direct effect on the particles themselves. Whether psionics is controlled subspace energy or the means of controllign said energy would be a matter of definition of the word. This is why I am talking about "psionic energy" instead of psionics, as that would be the means of control. Psionic energy is the energy being controlled to have an effect on the environment. You need some kind of scientifically sensible interaction and psionic energy applying directed kinetic energy to objects on a sub-molecular level is honestly the best idea I can come up with.
For the necessity of psionics being responsible for "paranormal activity", the combination of a)psionic energy in subspace, b)psionic nodes being a connector allowing for that energy to influence realspace and c)psionic nodes being present in any human, is what creates the census as well, making it unneccessary to view it as a "force of nature".
On energy sources you wrote this:I personally do not like the concept of the energy being produced by the psionically capable individual. I think that would require an overly complex mechanism that could not be reliably replicated by technology. Keep in mind that "psionic nodes drawing power fron subspace" would not be OP, as every node only allows a certain ammount of energy through, which would quickly dissipate and be quite hard to store, so an average psionic won't be capable of much beyond telepathy without technological or genetical aid. Psionic technology would operate by artificially maintaining a psionic node. Creating such an artificial psionic node would work by one of two means: a) focusing a lot of ambient psionic energy on a suitable "carrier" and mimicking the mechanism in the brain, hoping to cause a reaction and open a node. This method can only create limited ammounts of energy, for example a single psionic ship-to-ship weapon would require about 10 of those carriers. b) dimensional manipulation, would propably only become feasible in the far-future as described in your model. It would allow to create much larger nodes. This type would however be required to construct psionic subspace drives (note: change of plans, my faction will not start into the galaxy with psi-FTL. psi-FTL would only be developed much later, around the same time as regular subspace drives, due to the requirement of dimensional subspace manipulation being already available).catsonmeth wrote:The other issue is the energy source and means to broadcast the energy over distances. The energy could come from the organism itself. The average human takes in about 2000 kilocalories per day, which is about 2 KG TNT energy equivalent. Metabolism could be heightened by the wetware and used to feed it. Devices could also be used to gather ambient energy and store it, or just create their own. Interdimensional energy might also be a source, but only in the far-future.
" We explore... and you call us criminals. We seek after knowledge, and you call us criminals.We exist without skin color, without nationality, without religous bias... and you call us criminals.You build atomic bombs, you wage wars, you murder, cheat, and lie to us and try to make us believe it's for our own good, yet we're the
criminals.Yes, I am a crimial. My crime is that of curiosity."
EMPRAH * BRUVA
criminals.Yes, I am a crimial. My crime is that of curiosity."
EMPRAH * BRUVA
-
- Fleet Admiral
- Posts:3021
- Joined:Fri Dec 07, 2012 12:10 pm
- Affiliation:[redacted]
- IGN:Ivan2006
- Location:In a universe.
- Contact:
Re: RP reset: psionics
That sounds like something Miranda would quote.Crash Override wrote:The limit of the Willing Suspension of Disbelief for a given element is directly proportional to the element's awesomeness.
Quotes:
Spoiler:
-
- Lt. Commander
- Posts:781
- Joined:Fri Dec 07, 2012 5:00 pm
- Affiliation:Darkstar Security CO
- Location:Brazil.
Re: RP reset: psionics
Ivan2006 wrote:That sounds like something Miranda would quote.Crash Override wrote:The limit of the Willing Suspension of Disbelief for a given element is directly proportional to the element's awesomeness.
Yes,it is.
Also,a message about planet busters
Spoiler:
" We explore... and you call us criminals. We seek after knowledge, and you call us criminals.We exist without skin color, without nationality, without religous bias... and you call us criminals.You build atomic bombs, you wage wars, you murder, cheat, and lie to us and try to make us believe it's for our own good, yet we're the
criminals.Yes, I am a crimial. My crime is that of curiosity."
EMPRAH * BRUVA
criminals.Yes, I am a crimial. My crime is that of curiosity."
EMPRAH * BRUVA
-
- Fleet Admiral
- Posts:3021
- Joined:Fri Dec 07, 2012 12:10 pm
- Affiliation:[redacted]
- IGN:Ivan2006
- Location:In a universe.
- Contact:
Re: RP reset: psionics
So what you're saying is that if stuff is awesome, people won't care if it's realistic?
You can argue that out with the board of GMs.
According to them, everything needs an explanation.
I am just trying to supply a good explanation for psionics here.
Unless it wasn't a critique, in which case I have no idea what it would be, so sorry then.
You can argue that out with the board of GMs.
According to them, everything needs an explanation.
I am just trying to supply a good explanation for psionics here.
Unless it wasn't a critique, in which case I have no idea what it would be, so sorry then.
Quotes:
Spoiler:
-
- Lt. Commander
- Posts:781
- Joined:Fri Dec 07, 2012 5:00 pm
- Affiliation:Darkstar Security CO
- Location:Brazil.
Re: RP reset: psionics
No i was just reading stuff about sci-fi,its not critique
It was supposed to be funny,nevermind then
It was supposed to be funny,nevermind then
" We explore... and you call us criminals. We seek after knowledge, and you call us criminals.We exist without skin color, without nationality, without religous bias... and you call us criminals.You build atomic bombs, you wage wars, you murder, cheat, and lie to us and try to make us believe it's for our own good, yet we're the
criminals.Yes, I am a crimial. My crime is that of curiosity."
EMPRAH * BRUVA
criminals.Yes, I am a crimial. My crime is that of curiosity."
EMPRAH * BRUVA
-
- Vice Admiral
- Posts:2623
- Joined:Thu Dec 06, 2012 9:46 pm
- Affiliation:Nivanshae
- IGN:_Shadowcat_
- Location:Munching on important looking wires.
Re: RP reset: psionics
Space magic.
In yo ceiling, stealin yo wires
Do not open. Ever. At all. Enter at your own risk to life and limb.
Trigger warning
Bot gore warning
Memetic biohazard
Error bait
Do not open. Ever. At all. Enter at your own risk to life and limb.
Trigger warning
Bot gore warning
Memetic biohazard
Error bait
Spoiler:
Re: RP reset: psionics
Psionics is a word that's already defined. Subspace has been in place since the FTL thread months ago. We aren't going to add another kind of fundamental energy. You're literally proposing that we add magic and trying to turn a defined generality into a specification. It's like someone saying that their specialization is all FTL then inventing a magical force that makes things go past c and saying that all other FTL doesn't exist.
The electromagnetic force exerted on a thing by an electromagnet is electromagnetic.
We aren't Star Wars and we won't use retarded physics to make our universe because it's "cool."
The electromagnetic force exerted on a thing by an electromagnet is electromagnetic.
We aren't Star Wars and we won't use retarded physics to make our universe because it's "cool."
"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from a completely ad-hoc plot device"
— David Langford
— David Langford
Spoiler:
-
- Fleet Admiral
- Posts:3021
- Joined:Fri Dec 07, 2012 12:10 pm
- Affiliation:[redacted]
- IGN:Ivan2006
- Location:In a universe.
- Contact:
Re: RP reset: psionics
Catsonmeth, would you kindly link me to the definition of psionics you are using here?
Because it seems I don't happen to know it.
Because it seems I don't happen to know it.
Quotes:
Spoiler:
Re: RP reset: psionics
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psionics
http://powerlisting.wikia.com/wiki/Psionics
http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/de ... sh/psionic
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/psionic
Psionics
Psionics is an umbrella term used by parapsychologists to describe psychic abilities such as telepathy, psychokinesis, pyrokinesis and others.
http://powerlisting.wikia.com/wiki/Psionics
http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/de ... sh/psionic
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/psionic
Psionics
Psionics is an umbrella term used by parapsychologists to describe psychic abilities such as telepathy, psychokinesis, pyrokinesis and others.
"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from a completely ad-hoc plot device"
— David Langford
— David Langford
Spoiler:
-
- Fleet Admiral
- Posts:3021
- Joined:Fri Dec 07, 2012 12:10 pm
- Affiliation:[redacted]
- IGN:Ivan2006
- Location:In a universe.
- Contact:
Re: RP reset: psionics
Have a detailed description as to why none of your posted sources make other forms of psionics neccessary by defimnition.
Essentially, yes, there can be other things that may be psionic, even if we only use the cross-section of all 4 definitions as psionics.
However, there is no need for that. My thing pretty much fills that cross-section entirely, and as I wrote in the Spoiler, even Wikipedia states that it just refers to a collection of abilities that without the connection by psionics would be viewed as independent from each other. aka psionic abilities. We do not violate this definition if we decide that the primary criteria for an ability to be psionic is that it functions on the basis of psionic energy. Because what psionic abilities there are is still largely the buiseness of the universe you apply this to.
And I would also make a clearification: My faction would not be specialized in psionics as in they are the only ones who have it.
The idea is that we propably are the most advanced in terms of technological applications for psionics and that we have a higher rate of psionics in the population than other factions.
On the electromagnet example, you may not have gotten the point: the psionic force exerted on an object that makes it levitate in the case of psionic levitation would be exactly as much a force of nature as the electromagnetic force exerted by an electromagnet.
I agree that we are not Star Wars. That is why I tried to make a somewhat scientific explanation to Psionics.
Because in all honesty, you will have trouble making an explanation as to how psionics work and not even have it sounding a bit like the Force from SW, simply because the general idea of the Force gets pretty close to what most members here have as a general idea on what psionics are.
I have also included several limitations to how psionics can be applied without them seeming artificial, as they are implemented in the basic principles.
Remember, as in every science, you get your basic principles and aéverythign else just turns out to be application of those principles.
So I don't really see where "retarded physics" were used in my description.
You can have our quantum physicist Fenway double-check my stuff if he finds any "retarded" contents that need ironing, but unless you actually have any valid reason to call BS on my thing other than "I don't like it" and do not have a better idea (which should propably be accurate enough to not break your other rule of "give an explanation to every tech" for technical applications of psionics, such as a "just roll with it"-system would do, since that way no one knows how to write psionic tech because we don't have any clear rules for psionics, which would end up with a very large mess, in the early 4th millenium, if not earlier, as at that time, everyone would have functioning psionics, all working on their user's private view on the topic), please stop trying to shoot down my psionics.
You can continue bringing up issues, and I will continue taking them down.
Spoiler:
However, there is no need for that. My thing pretty much fills that cross-section entirely, and as I wrote in the Spoiler, even Wikipedia states that it just refers to a collection of abilities that without the connection by psionics would be viewed as independent from each other. aka psionic abilities. We do not violate this definition if we decide that the primary criteria for an ability to be psionic is that it functions on the basis of psionic energy. Because what psionic abilities there are is still largely the buiseness of the universe you apply this to.
And I would also make a clearification: My faction would not be specialized in psionics as in they are the only ones who have it.
The idea is that we propably are the most advanced in terms of technological applications for psionics and that we have a higher rate of psionics in the population than other factions.
On the electromagnet example, you may not have gotten the point: the psionic force exerted on an object that makes it levitate in the case of psionic levitation would be exactly as much a force of nature as the electromagnetic force exerted by an electromagnet.
I agree that we are not Star Wars. That is why I tried to make a somewhat scientific explanation to Psionics.
Because in all honesty, you will have trouble making an explanation as to how psionics work and not even have it sounding a bit like the Force from SW, simply because the general idea of the Force gets pretty close to what most members here have as a general idea on what psionics are.
I have also included several limitations to how psionics can be applied without them seeming artificial, as they are implemented in the basic principles.
Remember, as in every science, you get your basic principles and aéverythign else just turns out to be application of those principles.
So I don't really see where "retarded physics" were used in my description.
You can have our quantum physicist Fenway double-check my stuff if he finds any "retarded" contents that need ironing, but unless you actually have any valid reason to call BS on my thing other than "I don't like it" and do not have a better idea (which should propably be accurate enough to not break your other rule of "give an explanation to every tech" for technical applications of psionics, such as a "just roll with it"-system would do, since that way no one knows how to write psionic tech because we don't have any clear rules for psionics, which would end up with a very large mess, in the early 4th millenium, if not earlier, as at that time, everyone would have functioning psionics, all working on their user's private view on the topic), please stop trying to shoot down my psionics.
You can continue bringing up issues, and I will continue taking them down.
Quotes:
Spoiler: